Cash-Out Refinance vs HELOC vs Home Equity Loan: Compared

A cash-out refinance, a home equity line of credit (HELOC), and a home equity loan all let you borrow against your home's equity. What sets them apart is what happens to the mortgage you already have.
A cash-out refinance, a home equity line of credit (HELOC), and a home equity loan all let you borrow against your home's equity. What sets them apart is what happens to the mortgage you already have.

A cash-out refinance, a home equity line of credit (HELOC), and a home equity loan all let you borrow against your home’s equity. What sets them apart is what happens to the mortgage you already have.

Cash-Out Refinance vs HELOC: The Short Answer

When you compare a cash-out refinance vs a HELOC, start with one question: does the loan replace your current mortgage, or sit beside it? Only a cash-out refinance replaces your first mortgage. A HELOC and a home equity loan add a second loan on top of it. A HELOC gives you a credit line to draw from over time, and a home equity loan, sometimes called a second mortgage, pays out a lump sum up front. The table below lines up the details.

Cash-out refinance, HELOC, and home equity loan compared (sources: Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), Federal Trade Commission (FTC), Freddie Mac)

Feature Cash-out refinance HELOC Home equity loan
How you get the money The difference between the new loan and your old balance, paid in cash A credit line you draw from as needed A lump sum up front
Your current mortgage Paid off and replaced Stays in place Stays in place
How the rate works The new rate applies to your whole mortgage Usually variable, so payments can change (CFPB) Fixed or adjustable (CFPB)
How you repay Regular payments on the new mortgage Draw period first, then repayment, often over 10 or 20 years (CFPB) Regular monthly payments
Costs to expect Costs to refinance, often 3% to 6% of the loan principal (Freddie Mac) Interest and fees (FTC) Interest and fees (FTC)
What secures the loan Your home Your home Your home

 

What a Cash-Out Refinance Changes

For the full definition, see what a cash-out refinance is. For this comparison, what matters is what it does to your current mortgage: the new loan replaces it, so the new rate and terms apply to the whole balance.

Say your home is worth $500,000, and you owe $300,000. Here is how the numbers could work:

  • Equity (the home’s value minus what you owe): $200,000
  • Largest new mortgage, if a program lets you borrow up to 80% of the home’s value: $400,000
  • Cash before closing costs: roughly $100,000
  • Cash after refinancing costs of 3% to 6% of the $400,000 loan: roughly $76,000 to $88,000

Your actual amount depends on the appraisal, your balance, your credit, and the program’s limits.

Refinancing carries costs, and Freddie Mac says you can expect to spend 3% to 6% of your loan principal. If your current rate is lower than the new one, replacing the mortgage means giving that lower rate up on your full balance. The CFPB tells borrowers to weigh the new rate carefully, especially if it is higher than the rate on their current mortgage.

MVP Funding helps homeowners explore refinancing, including a cash-out refinance.

How a HELOC Works

A HELOC lets you borrow against your equity again and again, up to a limit, instead of taking one lump sum. The borrowing period is called the draw period, and the CFPB’s HELOC guide gives 10 years as an example. When it ends, you can no longer borrow, and the lender sets a schedule to repay the full balance, often over 10 or 20 years.

Four things to know about HELOC payments:

  • The CFPB says monthly payments are often significantly higher once you enter repayment
  • Many HELOCs have minimum monthly payments based on your current balance, so what you owe depends on how much of the line you have used
  • HELOCs usually have a variable interest rate, so your payment can change from month to month
  • Some HELOCs let you convert to a fixed rate, which the CFPB says is usually higher than the variable rate but more predictable

Your first mortgage stays as it is. Because your home secures the line, falling behind on payments could cost you the home, as it can with any loan secured by your home.

How a Home Equity Loan Works

A home equity loan pays out a lump sum up front and is secured by your home. It is sometimes called a second mortgage, and you make its payments in addition to your first mortgage payments. The CFPB says you typically borrow all the money at once and repay it in regular monthly payments, and the rate may be fixed or adjustable.

Using the same example, you would still owe $300,000 on your first mortgage and add the new loan on top of it. If a lender gave you a $100,000 home equity loan, you would receive $100,000 once and owe $400,000 in total, split across two loans with two monthly payments. Lenders set their own limits on how much you can borrow, so this is only an illustration. The terms of your first mortgage would not change.

Because the same home secures both loans, selling the home means paying both off, and the CFPB notes that repayment of a home equity loan is often required when you sell.

Costs and Risks to Compare

All three options cost money. As with other mortgages, you pay interest and fees on a home equity loan or a HELOC, according to the Federal Trade Commission, and a cash-out refinance often comes with closing costs. Ask each lender for its fees in writing before you compare offers.

To compare costs, look at your total debt after each option.

All three also use your home as collateral. If you do not repay as agreed, the lender can foreclose on your home. A cash-out refinance adds the cash you take to your mortgage balance, which may lengthen how long it takes to pay the home off.

Taxes depend on how you use the money. IRS Publication 936 (2025 edition) says interest on home equity loans and lines of credit is deductible only if you use the money to buy, build, or substantially improve the home that secures the loan. A tax professional can tell you how that rule applies to you, including how it applies to a cash-out refinance.

Cash-Out Refinance vs HELOC vs Home Equity Loan: Which Fits

Cash-out refinance vs home equity loan comes down to whether you are willing to replace your current mortgage. Neither option is simply better — it depends on your specific situation. Three questions point toward a fit: do you want to keep your current mortgage as it is, do you need the money once or over time, and how do you plan to repay it? Here is how the answers tend to line up:

Home equity loan: you want to keep your current mortgage and need one lump sum for a single expense with a known cost

HELOC: you want to borrow as you go, such as a renovation paid out in phases, and can live with a payment that changes and can rise when the draw period ends

Cash-out refinance: you would rather have one loan and one payment, and you are comfortable replacing your current mortgage, which resets the whole loan

If you are not sure you need to borrow against your equity at all, remember that every option here puts your home behind a new debt. When the money is for something that can wait or be paid another way, compare the cost of borrowing with what you would gain before you apply.

Questions to Ask Any Lender Before You Choose

Whichever option you lean toward, get the terms in writing so you can compare them line by line. Have four numbers ready before you ask: your current mortgage balance, the rate on it, a realistic estimate of your home’s value, and the amount of cash you need. Then ask each lender:

  • Does this loan replace my current mortgage, or add to it?
  • How is the rate set, and can it change?
  • What fees and closing costs apply, and when do I pay them?
  • What will my payments look like after any draw period ends?
  • If the terms change before closing, what will I be told, and when?

If you are still deciding whether to refinance at all, Should I Refinance My Mortgage? walks through the break-even math.

See What a Cash-Out Refinance Could Look Like for You

If a cash-out refinance fits your plans, the next step is to talk through your own numbers. MVP Funding can walk you through a cash-out refinance and what it would change on your current mortgage.

[See Your Cash-Out Options]

MVP Funding is a mortgage broker and a d/b/a of Milestone Mortgage Solutions, LLC (NMLS #1815656). This is not a commitment to lend or extend credit. All loans are subject to credit approval.

More From MVP

See all blogs & Articles